Over the past year, I have posted numerous Articles which in part deal with Debt Forgiveness and the receipt of a 1099 form from a lender. Now, as we’re seeing lawsuits being filed by some lenders to collect on unpaid debt after foreclosure, borrowers are saying “Wait… they gave me a 1099! Doesn’t that mean the debt is forgiven?” The answer is maybe.
A 1099 is simply a type of IRS form used to report income other than wages, salaries, and tips. The most common forms are: 1099-Misc to report miscellaneous income; 1099-Div to report dividend income; and the 1099-Int to report interest income. Following foreclosure two different forms of 1099 are used: the 1099-C to report cancelled debt; and the 1099-A to report the acquisition or abandonment of a secured property. It is this last one that causes the confusion and no doubt will be the subject of litigation.
The 1099-A contains several boxes, one of which requires the lender to state whether the borrower was personally liable for the debt or not. If there is no liability (such as in California with acquisition debt or following the lender’s Trustee Sale), then the unpaid debt amount is forgiven and debt forgiveness tax can be assessed (unless an exclusion applies). This gives the same result as the 1099-C. But… where the 1099-A states that the borrower is personally liable, then the filing of the 1099-A might not mean debt is forgiven. Rather, it may mean that the lender has only filed the form to designate that an event has occurred and they have not as yet determined whether or not to cancel, ie: forgive, the debt. This is a very confusing result.
You can learn more about the use of 1099-C and 1099-A on IRS Publication 4681: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p4681.pdf. For any of you Accountants reading this, if you can shed more light on this, please post a Reply or e-mail me at sjbeede@bpelaw.com.
Watch this Blog for further insight as this issue gains greater clarity. We’re just starting to provide defenses for borrowers sued by wiped out junior lenders and the role of the 1099 may be an important defense argument (as well as the many other defenses that may exist). Remember, lenders want to try to get paid but they don’t want to throw good money after bad. If there is some recourse, a settlement may be the fastest and most cost-effective result for everyone.
If you’re facing a post-foreclosure lawsuit or have any questions concerning upside-down loans or your rights and obligations concerning real property, foreclosure, or any related issues, please feel free to contact me at stevebeede@bpelaw.com or contact my office at 916 966-2260 for a confidential appointment by phone or in person.
